Two week lead time
Simple cakes require at least two weeks' notice. Please plan your pickup or delivery date accordingly.
Simple cakes
We make the cake. You make it yours.
Simple cakes are smooth, sharp-edged buttercream cakes made from scratch and finished in your choice of color. Simply add your own topper, flowers, sprinkles, or personal touch to make it yours.
$50
6-inch round
Serves 8–10
$70
8-inch round
Serves 12–16
$80
6-inch tall cake
Serves 12–16
$120
6 & 8-inch 2-tier
Serves 22–26
What is a simple cake?
A simple cake is a fully baked and iced cake with a smooth, sharp-edge buttercream finish in the color of your choice. It comes with no decorations, writing, or added design — just a beautifully finished cake. Once you pick it up, it's yours to do with as you please.
Smooth sharp-edge finish
Clean, professional buttercream iced to a sharp edge
No custom decorating
No toppers, writing, or design work — just a perfect finish
Light colors only
Any light shade — keep it soft and light, no dark or bold colors
Cake flavors
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Red Velvet
- Lemon
- Coconut
- Cookie Butter
- Strawberry
- Lemon Blueberry
- Carrot
- Almond
Buttercream fillings
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Cookies & Cream
- Strawberry
- Raspberry
- Coconut
- Cookie Butter
- Peanut Butter
- Salted Caramel
- Nutella
- Cream Cheese
- White Chocolate
Toppings
- Chocolate Ganache
- White Chocolate Ganache
- Salted Caramel Sauce
- Fresh Strawberries
- Strawberry Jam
- Raspberry Jam
Buttercream colors
We offer light colors only for the smooth outer finish. Any soft, light shade works — just describe what you have in mind in your order notes and we'll do our best to match. No dark or bold colors.
Good to know
No custom decorating
Simple cakes are finished with a smooth buttercream exterior only. I no longer offer custom design or decorating — what you get is a beautifully finished blank canvas.
Pickup or delivery
Pickup is available in Columbia, PA or Millersville, PA. Local delivery is also available for an additional fee. All orders are available Monday–Saturday, 9 AM–3 PM.
Full payment secures your order
After your inquiry is confirmed, an invoice will be sent. Your cake is reserved once payment is received in full.
Order a simple cake
Fill out the form below and I'll get back to you to confirm availability and send an invoice.
About payment
After your order is confirmed, I'll send an invoice. Your date is only secured once the invoice is paid in full — payment is due within 48 hours of receiving the invoice or the date will be released.